Followers

Thursday, 13 October 2016

Apartheid in South Africa



The year 1950 marked a step backwards in the path to global racial equality. On 27th April the government of South Africa passed the Group Areas Act into law, thus institutionalising the policy of Apartheid that was advocated by the National Party that had formed the government since 1948.

What is meant by Apartheid?

Apartheid is an Afrikaans word that can be translated as “separate-hood”, by which was meant that the different races that constituted the population of South Africa would be forced to integrate as little as possible. The whites who ran the National Party preferred the term “separate development”, but there was little intention that any race other than the white one would do much developing.

Instituting Apartheid

Under the direction of Prime Minister Daniel Malan, the three racial groups of Whites, Blacks and Coloureds (meaning people of mixed race) would be forced to live in separate areas, with neighbourhoods reserved for each racial group. As might be imagined, this soon meant that the rich whites would have the best houses and facilities, with the blacks and coloureds consigned to sub-standard housing on the margins of the cities.

A second act, the Separate Amenities Act, was passed in 1953 to make the division even more pronounced. This required all sorts of services to be reserved for the sole use of whites, including shops, transport, beaches, and even park benches. Again, the minority white population was always accorded the best facilities with the majority blacks always being made aware of their inferior status.

Another Act, the 1956 Separate Representation of Voters Act, virtually disenfranchised all non-whites and ensured that their only purpose in society was to work as servants of white people and as the manual workforce in the farms and factories owned by their white masters.

The struggle for freedom

The opposition to Apartheid took a long time to bear fruit in South Africa. The protest movements of black activists were met with savage repression, most notably at Sharpeville on 21st March 1960 when 69 people, including women and children, were killed by armed police officers.
Underground opposition movements were founded, including the African National Congress and the Black Consciousness Movement, but activists were regularly arrested and imprisoned. However, prisoners such as Nelson Mandela and Oliver Tambo made plans for how they would eventually defeat Apartheid and form a government that had room for all the racial groups in South Africa.

Support for the cause grew rapidly during the 1960s and 70s in western countries, with the National Party coming under increasing scrutiny and various sanctions being imposed on South Africa.

Particularly noteworthy were bans on South African sports teams from international competition unless they were racially integrated. The country was not allowed to compete at the Olympic Games from 1964 to 1988, for example, but some international sporting bodies were ambivalent and more accepting of South African participation during the Apartheid era.

One event that drew close attention to Apartheid in sport was the “D’Oliveira affair” of 1968. Basil D’Oliveira (1931-2011) was a mixed-race cricketer who was born in South Africa but emigrated to the United Kingdom and became a British citizen in 1964. He was selected to play for the England tour to South Africa in 1968-9 despite it being made known by the South Africans (led by Prime Minister John Vorster) that he would not be welcome. The affair escalated into a worldwide boycott of South African cricket that lasted until 1991.

The end of Apartheid

Worldwide pressure, coupled with largely peaceful internal demonstrations, eventually persuaded white South Africans that Apartheid could not be maintained and that majority rule would have to be conceded.

Credit for the peaceful transfer of power is due to two men in particular, namely President F W de Klerk and the leader of the African National Congress, Nelson Mandela. De Klerk realised that Apartheid was a thing of the past, and that it could not be justified morally or in any other way.

The move that caught the world’s attention as marking the beginning of the end of Apartheid was the release from prison in 1990 of Nelson Mandela after 27 years in captivity. He was immediately recognised as the leader of the black community and he was clearly the person most suited to conduct the negotiations that culminated in the 1994 election of a new government. More than 20 million black South Africans cast their votes, which swept Mandela into power as the country’s first black President.

The stain of Apartheid has therefore been lifted from South Africa which, although it still has many problems to solve, has now been restored to the world community of nations.


© John Welford

Monday, 3 October 2016

The Aberfan pit heap disaster, 1966



The pit heap disaster that happened in the village of Aberfan on 21st October 1966 was one that shocked the nation, especially because most of the victims were young children.


Disaster in South Wales

I can still remember the profound sense of shock that the whole United Kingdom felt on 21st October 1966 when part of a colliery slag heap slid down a hillside and smashed into houses and a school in the South Wales village of Aberfan, killing 116 children and 28 adults. I was still at school, and the thought of being in one’s classroom one minute and smothered to death under tons of slurry the next gave rise to a sense of horror that has never left me. Fortunately, the lessons that were learned from the Aberfan disaster have prevented anything similar happening again in this country.


Aberfan and its pit heaps

Aberfan is a small village in the valley of the River Taff, five miles south of Merthyr Tydfil in the central part of what was once the South Wales coalfield. The Taff is one of several rivers that have carved out parallel valleys along which the pit villages were built, strung out in an approximate north-south direction. Between the valleys are bare, steep-sided hills, and it was on these hills that the waste material from centuries of coalmining was piled in vast artificial hills that dominated the towns and villages below.

The danger posed by these heaps had been noted several years before the disaster, and in particular the practice of the National Coal Board in authorising the dumping of slurry from the Merthyr Vale Colliery on top of the existing tip to the rear of Pantglas School, on Moy Road, Aberfan. Engineers from the local authority had noted the fluid nature of the slurry and warned that, under wet conditions, it was unlikely to stay in place on such a steep slope. However, no action was taken and slurry continued to be added to the heap.


The moving heap

The days before the disaster had been wet, although 21st October was dry and sunny up on the hills, albeit foggy in the valley. Shortly after 9.00am, as the men up on the slag heap added another load, the point was reached where the heap crossed the line of stability and a huge mass of slurry broke away. The men were unable to warn anyone of the slide because it broke the telephone line that was their only means of communication. They could only watch helplessly as the slurry headed off down the mountainside into the fog that shrouded Aberfan.

Down below, the children at Pantglas Junior School had just returned to their classrooms after morning assembly, and the teachers were telling their charges to settle down and get their books ready, when a terrible rumbling noise was heard. Very few of the school’s occupants knew what was happening before the slurry hit the single-storey school and caved in the back wall, burying much of the interior up to the level of the roof. Some of the children instinctively hid under their desks and some survived because of this, but many were not so lucky. Hardly anyone survived from the classrooms at the back of the school.

As well as the school, some twenty houses in Moy Road were also hit, as was a farm cottage in the path of the slide that was carried away with all its inhabitants. Most of the 28 adults who died were in these houses and the cottage.


Rescue attempts and the aftermath

When the slurry stopped sliding there was silence at first as the survivors looked on in shock and horror at what had happened. Then there began a desperate effort to dig people out of the slurry, particularly from the villagers who rushed to the school as soon as they were aware of what had happened. Many of them had, not long before, left their own children at the school and had just got home when they heard the terrible rumbling as the slurry bore down on them through the mist.

The would-be rescuers had only their bare hands for tools as they scrambled through the mess to try to reach those buried underneath. There were a few successful rescues but very few; after 11.00 that morning there were only dead bodies to be found.

The 116 children who died (together with five of their teachers) were about half of the school’s total number. They therefore represented a substantial portion of the village’s next generation. Many of their fathers were underground in the pit at the time of the disaster, and their profound shock at being told the news was to affect many for the rest of their lives. They had always imagined that they were the ones at risk of sudden death, and the cruel irony that it was the waste product of their industry that had killed their children was extremely hard to bear.


The Inquiry and Disaster Fund

A Tribunal of Inquiry into the disaster was announced in Parliament within days, even before the last of the bodies had been removed from the school. The Tribunal sat for 76 days and heard evidence from 136 witnesses, the eventual documentation running to 2.5 million words. The main point at issue was whether this was an unforeseeable accident or whether blame could be attached to any specific persons or organizations.

The final report that was published on 3rd August 1967 did not mince its words:

“The Aberfan Disaster is a terrifying tale of bungling ineptitude by many men charged with tasks for which they were totally unfitted, of failure to heed clear warnings, and of total lack of direction from above. Not villains but decent men, led astray by foolishness or by ignorance or by both in combination, are responsible for what happened at Aberfan.”

One significant piece of evidence was the fact that a natural spring emerged underneath the pit heap, which therefore kept the base of the heap permanently lubricated. It was therefore only a matter of time before the continual loading of slurry would cause the heap to collapse. At first the National Coal Board officials denied having known about this spring, but they were eventually forced to acknowledge that it was known about and people had trusted to luck that nothing bad would happen.

With the blame laid firmly on the National Coal Board, would any individuals be held to account? Nine people were singled out for criticism, but no proceedings were taken against them. Likewise, the Coal Board was not required to pay the full amount of compensation to the victims’ families that might have been expected. One problem was that the coal industry was in financial difficulties, and bankrupting the Coal Board (a public body) would have helped no-one.

However, the British public contributed generously to a Disaster Fund which eventually raised £1.75 million. It was nothing short of a scandal that some of this money (some £150,000) had to be used to fund the removal of the remaining pit heaps above Aberfan, as this was clearly the responsibility of the National Coal Board. It was not until 1997 that this money was finally refunded by the Government.


Aberfan today

Visitors to Aberfan today will see a peaceful, quiet village that is safe for ever from the threat of a slurry slide, as the heaps have all gone. Indeed, the village is bypassed by a road that goes through the place where the heaps once stood. The school was demolished and in its place is a memorial garden, next door to a community centre that was built by the trustees of the Aberfan Disaster Fund. Up on the hillside are the graves of about half the victims, marked by a stone monument.

The lesson of Aberfan is that corporate greed must never again be allowed to put innocent lives at danger. By taking unwarranted shortcuts and ignoring clear warnings, the officials of the National Coal Board put the pursuit of profit above the safety of their employees and their families, much as their predecessors had done in the dark days of the early Industrial Revolution. The Aberfan disaster was a “one-off”, thankfully, because it brought home to the managers of British industry, in all sectors, the fact that they cannot put their responsibilities to one side whenever it suits them.

Aberfan will long be remembered, and not just in the South Wales valleys where the disaster was felt most keenly.



© John Welford

Wednesday, 21 September 2016

The sinking of the Lusitania



The sinking of RMS Lusitania on 7th May 1915 – the victim of a torpedo fired from a German U-boat - has long been regarded as a major war crime and a prime cause of the United States entering World War I. However, there are questions that are still unanswered.

Lusitania was launched on 7th June 1906 at John Brown’s shipyard on the Clyde, Glasgow. She was a massive ocean liner, 790 feet long with four enormous funnels. At the time she was the fastest and most luxurious liner afloat and was expected to make huge profits for the Cunard Line as she plied her trade on the Atlantic between the United States and Europe.

Lusitania entered service in 1907 and soon fulfilled the promises made for her. Her maiden voyage won the coveted Blue Riband for the fastest Atlantic crossing, at an average speed of 23.99 knots, and she bettered that record in 1909 with a speed of 25.85 knots.

She was clearly a more fortunate ship than the Titanic, in that she crossed the Atlantic more than 200 times.

However, her luck ran out after the start of World War I, when Germany declared that they regarded all the seas around the British Isles as a war zone. Any ship, military or civilian, would be seen as a legitimate target.

The sinking

On 1st May 1915 Lusitania left New York with 1,201 passengers and 702 crew members. Most of the passengers were British but 188 of them were American. At the time, the United States was in a state of neutrality in what it regarded as a purely European war. It was generally thought that a ship that had nothing to do with the war, and which was carrying a substantial number of Americans, would have been protected from attack on the grounds of this neutrality.

However, the German view, as mentioned above, was different. A U-boat, captained by Walter Schwieger, was waiting in the waters off the coast of Ireland. When Lusitania, moving slowly because of fog, came into range in the early afternoon of 7th May she was hit by a single torpedo. To everyone’s further surprise the ship was immediately rocked by a second huge explosion.

Panic ensued on board as the passengers rushed for the 48 lifeboats, many of which could not be launched due to the listing of the ship to one side. Other boats tipped their passengers into the sea as Lusitania lurched downwards. Only six lifeboats were launched successfully.

Captain Turner of the Lusitania only abandoned ship when the water reached the bridge. He clung to a floating chair and was eventually rescued. However, the sinking claimed a total of 1,198 lives, including 63 children and 128 Americans.

The fact that there were more than 700 survivors, despite the rapid sinking of the ship in 18 minutes and the chaos involving the lifeboats, was due in large part to the relative closeness of the ship to the Irish coast, so that rescue vessels were able to reach the scene in time to pull many people from the water before they drowned or froze to death. This situation was somewhat different to the plight of the victims of Titanic in the ice-strewn open ocean three years previously.

Explosives on board?

The German government sought to justify the attack by claiming that Lusitania was a legitimate target because she was carrying a large quantity of explosives destined for the British Army. This, they said, was the cause of the second explosion that followed that resulting from the torpedo impact. Had this been true, it would of course have called into question the supposed neutrality of the United States.

However, there were other possible causes of the second explosion, including the ship’s boilers blowing up and the ignition of coal dust in the fuel hold.

The wreck of Lusitania lies in relatively shallow water at a depth of around 300 feet. This has allowed the wreck to be explored, and large quantities of rifle ammunition have been discovered. It is also believed that the ship was carrying material that would have contributed to the manufacture of explosives, even if ready-made explosive items were not on board. These discoveries lend some weight to the original German claim, even if the second blast was not due to the direct explosion of war material.

The aftermath

Whatever the rights and wrongs of the matter, public opinion was swayed on both sides of the Atlantic and it cannot be doubted that the sinking of the Lusitania played a role in changing American minds. That said, another two years would pass before the United States entered the war.

There were even suggestions that the British government had engineered the tragedy as a means of getting America to enter the war on the side of the Allies. Knowing that German U-boats were in the area, why was such a large target as the Lusitania not offered any protection from the Royal Navy?

It is hardly to be wondered at that conspiracy theories abound on this incident as on so many others. Whether the whole truth will ever be known is another matter altogether.


© John Welford

Thursday, 25 August 2016

Bartholomew Steere and the North Oxfordshire Uprising, 1596



The prize for the least successful revolution to take place on British soil must surely go to the North Oxfordshire Uprising of 1596. A pre-requisite of a revolution must be that large numbers of people gather and makes demands for a better way of life – so ten men and a dog has to register as something of a failure.


Bartholomew Steere – would-be revolutionary

Bartholomew Steere was a young man who hoped to follow in his father’s footsteps as a tenant farmer in north Oxfordshire. As a way of life it was not particularly luxurious – farmers earned a meagre living at the best of times and were subject to all sorts of privations if things went wrong – but in most years a farmer could get by and keep his family fed.

However, change was afoot in the 16th century as landowners saw more profit in enclosing their fields and turning them into pastures for sheep than they could get from collecting rents from peasant farmers.

Bartholomew was determined to do something about it, so he canvassed opinion among other young men in the area. Before long he came up with a plan for a new “Peasants’ Revolt” that would be bound to make the landlords sit up and take notice.


The North Oxfordshire Uprising

Bartholomew put the word out that a revolt would take place and he asked people to gather on a named day at Enslow Hill, near the village of Bletchingdon (the hill has all but disappeared in more recent times, thanks to extensive quarrying). As evening fell the first of the revolutionaries climbed the hill, these being Bartholomew and nine others, one of whom brought his dog.

They confidently expected hundreds more people to turn up during the night, so they lit a fire, bedded down under the stars at the top of the hill, and waited for first light so that the gathered hordes could then march to confront their oppressors.

However, when dawn broke it became apparent that not a single extra person had joined them. They had no option but to put out the fire, descend the hill and go home. The revolution was well and truly over.


An unfortunate sequel

The whole affair might well have been forgotten about were it not that word reached a local vicar that a rebellion had been planned. He passed the news on, and when it reached the ears of the landowners they suddenly got the notion that the countryside was awash with violent revolutionaries. The result was little short of panic, although the ten men on the hill (and the dog) had long since given up any plans they might have had and were back working on their farms.

The government in London eventually got wind of the incident and issued arrest warrants for the four ringleaders, including Bartholomew Steere. Orders were given for how these dangerous criminals were to be treated on their journey to London for trial – being bound and gagged so that they couldn’t get word out to other revolutionaries who would attempt a rescue. Needless to say, nothing of the sort took place.

It all ended badly for Bartholomew and his companions. He and one of the others under arrest died from the tortures they were subjected to and the other two were taken back to Enslow Hill where they were hanged, drawn and quartered.

It has to be assumed that the reason why the Uprising never happened is that most of the would-be revolutionaries, who stayed at home rather than climb Enslow Hill, knew full well what the outcome would be. Any attempt to question the status quo, especially if violence was threatened, was regarded as treason against the state, and the punishments inflicted by the government were indeed in line with that interpretation.

One has therefore to conclude that Bartholomew Steere, although well-meaning, was extremely foolish to do what he did, although one might also conclude that, with a little more investigation into the circumstances, the government could have afforded to be more lenient towards a group of young men who were never going to pose a serious threat to public order.

As it was, the threatened enclosure of the common fields of north Oxfordshire did go ahead, with those of Bletchingdon being among the first to be affected. As Bartholomew Steere had feared, the old ways of rural living came to an end, accompanied by a great deal of suffering for those tenant farmers who could not adapt to the new regime. The fact remains that there was absolutely nothing that he and his fellows could have done about it.


© John Welford

Friday, 29 July 2016

Changes made to the Bayeux Tapestry



“Every schoolchild knows” – every British schoolchild that is – that King Harold II died at the Battle of Hastings in 1066 when an arrow struck him in the eye and penetrated into his brain. The evidence for this is plain to see in the dramatic “comic strip” that is the Bayeux Tapestry. However, the truth may not be as clear-cut as the scene displayed in that remarkable artefact.

The Bayeux Tapestry is about 70 metres (230 feet) long and half a metre (1.6 feet) wide. It is not actually a tapestry (which is woven) but a piece of embroidery, with all the scenes and text having been stitched in wool yarn on to a linen cloth that was left bare in many places.

It is now generally believed that the Tapestry was the work of English embroiders in the 1070s. They worked at Canterbury under the direction of Odo, the Norman Bishop of Bayeux, who wanted to display the Tapestry in his cathedral. It therefore tells the whole story of Duke William’s claim to the English throne, the invasion, and the Battle of Hastings. Odo’s own participation in the battle was to be carefully “spun” to show that he was essential to the eventual victory but did not actually do any fighting, which would be unbecoming for a bishop. The truth of this claim is disputed!

The Tapestry that can be seen today in Bayeux shows the death of Harold from an arrow in the eye quite clearly, but the question arises as to whether this was always the case. It would appear that the ladies of Canterbury had a certain amount of leeway in how they depicted certain events and often portrayed scenes from an English rather than a Norman perspective. As long as Odo was portrayed as he wanted, he was not too bothered about the details, so the embroiderers may have got away with quite a bit of sly propaganda of their own.


Changes to the Tapestry

There is plenty of evidence to suggest that the Tapestry was altered in several respects at various times during its long history. It is not surprising that a work of this kind would have needed restoration from time to time, but it certainly looks as though opportunities were taken to make changes that were more substantial than just replacing worn-out threads.

The finger of suspicion for the death of Harold scene points to restorers in the 19th century, because reproductions of the scene that were made at earlier times do not look the same as they do now.

A full-scale tracing was made in 1729. This shows Harold holding a spear, either because he is about to throw it or because he has just been struck by it. A set of facsimiles was made in 1819, but these show the spear as an arrow heading for Harold. By the time that a photograph was taken in 1872, the arrow is in Harold’s eye.


Why would anyone have wanted to make these changes?

Harold’s death now looks to have been clean and clinical – almost accidental, one might say. If the 1729 version was the original, it shows Harold fighting for his life in hand-to-hand combat. He is therefore a brave fighter and not the victim of a stray arrow, which might happen to anyone at some distance from the main event. The emphasis has therefore shifted from an English viewpoint to a Norman one.

There is, however, another possibility, which is that the original spear was so worn out by the time it was restored in the early 19th century that it was not clear that a spear had been intended at all. 

The restorers might have genuinely thought that the image was of an arrow, or they might simply have gone for the lazy option of replacing many stitches with a few.


How did Harold really die?

It is always possible that Harold did die from an arrow. This was stated in a chronicle written in 1080. However, there is a far more reliable account that dates from 1067 which is the “Song of the Battle of Hastings” written by Guy, the Bishop of Amiens.

According to Guy, Harold was hacked to death by a group of four knights who were acting on Duke William’s orders but who went much further than William wanted. Harold was struck in the chest (the spear in the original Tapestry image?) then beheaded, disembowelled, and had his genitals cut off. He was therefore treated with great dishonour, which even a general as vicious as William would not have countenanced as being the right way to despatch someone of royal blood.

Evidence for this account comes from the fact that Harold’s widow was the only person who could identify his mutilated remains after the battle. It was also reported that Duke William was so horrified that he demoted the knights in question and sent them home in disgrace.

It does not sound likely that the English embroiderers would have been allowed to portray the full horror of Harold’s death – had it been as reported – and they might not have wished to do so even if they could. However, even the sanitised version that they showed appears to be missing from the Bayeux Tapestry as it appears today.

The story of the arrow in the eye therefore continues to be what “every schoolchild knows”, despite the very flimsy evidence on which it is based.


© John Welford

Tuesday, 21 June 2016

The discovery of DNA's double helix, 1953



25th April 1953 is a date that should be commemorated worldwide, because it was on this day that the journal Nature published an article that would have far-reaching consequences.

The article was by two scientists from Cambridge University, James Watson and Francis Crick, and it announced their discovery of the molecular structure of deoxyribonucleic acid, which is better known by its initials as DNA. The discovery solved a problem that had puzzled scientists ever since Charles Darwin had published “The Origin of Species”, namely what the mechanism was by which living things were able to pass on their characteristics to the next generation, and what could cause changes to happen that would lead to the evolution of new species.

Crick and Watson

Francis Crick (1916-2004) and James Watson (born 1928) met at the Cavendish Laboratory of Cambridge University in 1951, where they became close friends as well as professional colleagues. Their work depended to a large extent on work done by others, notably Rosalind Franklin, Raymond Gosling and Maurice Wilkins. Of these, Franklin would have had most cause to be aggrieved at the lack of recognition given to her work, especially as it proved to be essential to the work of Crick and Watson.

The Double Helix

What Crick and Watson did was not to discover DNA as such – its existence was already well established – but to visualise how the molecule was constructed.  They were able to build a model that demonstrated the molecule as a “double helix”, or a long ladder-like structure in which the rungs comprise pairs of four possible bases – guanine, adenine, cytosine and thymine.

The order in which the pairs of bases are arranged forms a chemical code that instructs the cell to make a particular amino acid. Because the basic units are so simple, and because every strand of DNA contains the code for the entire organism, the full DNA strand is immensely long. If fully unravelled, the DNA in each cell would extend to more than two metres. All the DNA in a human body would stretch to 200 billion kilometres!

The double helix provides the clue to how DNA works. The “ladder” is able to split apart so that portions of DNA can act as templates for the assembly of new DNA, or strands of RNA (ribonucleic acid) can act as messengers in the building of new proteins.

DNA and evolution

Crick and Watson’s discovery paved the way for understanding how evolution works by providing the mechanism by which “errors” can be introduced into new generations of an organism. The splitting and re-assembly of DNA strands is not always perfect, which means that the chemical code can be distorted and new characteristics introduced that may or not be beneficial to the new individual.  When beneficial changes happen, these are likely to be passed on to future generations, which will therefore differ in some respect from what went before. Given enough time, and enough such DNA errors, new species can evolve.

Amazingly enough, there are still people in the world who refuse to believe the evidence that has been presented for all to see, and prefer to ascribe the variety of life on Earth to divine creation. These people would probably claim that black was white if the Bible said so!


© John Welford

Wednesday, 15 June 2016

Attitutes towards the British Empire




Every year, in September, the series of Promenade Concerts at London’s Royal Albert Hall reaches its last night and Britain suddenly rediscovers its patriotism. These days, we Brits are not much given to flag waving, but on the Last Night of the Proms (which is now extended to simultaneous events around the country and is broadcast live on TV and radio) there are flags a-plenty and enthusiastic renditions of patriotic songs including these lines from “Land of Hope and Glory”:

“Wider still and wider shall thy bounds be set / God, who made thee mighty, make thee mightier yet”.

Anyone from overseas who saw the crowds of mainly young people belting out these lines to the music of Elgar’s “Pomp and Circumstance March No 1” might imagine that the British people continue to be imperialist and jingoistic, nostalgically longing for the revival of Empire and seeking world domination once more. However, nobody should take these celebrations too seriously, because today’s Brits have a very different world-view from that of their great-grandparents who were around when those words were written back in 1902.


The red map

The British Empire was at its height in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, which was when maps of the world showed the largest proportion of the world’s territories coloured red. To the top left was Canada, to the bottom right, Australia. Other large red blocks included India and huge swathes of Africa. Island chains strung across the Pacific ensured that this was truly an empire “on which the sun never set”. At the centre of the map was the relatively tiny island of Great Britain, from which this whole enterprise was run. It is hardly to be wondered that the vast majority of the British people once took enormous pride in being the most powerful country in the world.

An important element of this pride, and one that is often forgotten, is that the Victorians regarded the Empire not only as proof of their superiority but as something that it was their sacred duty to maintain and extend. In 1893, Lord Rosebery, who was Foreign Secretary and would become Prime Minister, said in a speech that:

“We have to consider what countries must be developed … and we have to remember that it is part of our heritage to take care that the world, as far as it can be moulded by us, shall receive an English-speaking complexion and not that of other nations. [We must not] decline to take our share in a partition of the world, which we have not forced, but which has been forced on us.”

In terms of Africa and India, Britain was shouldering the “white man’s burden” of rescuing benighted peoples from the despair of being primitive, savage, un-Christian, and black-skinned. Seen from a modern perspective, this attitude was deeply racist, patronising and indeed hypocritical, in that the purpose of Empire was to receive as well as give.


Pros and cons of Empire

However, many British people at the time would not have regarded the Empire as being anything other than a force for good. They genuinely believed that their Christian religion required them to make converts of all the races of the world, and also that the white races were inherently superior to the black ones. (It is probably worth bearing in mind that there are still plenty of people around who think the same way.) Through the Empire, the Victorians and Edwardians were able to put these beliefs into practice. Their God, together with their finely-tuned Protestant work ethic, required them to serve, and the Empire gave them the opportunity to do so.

The Empire therefore affected the British people in very practical ways. Many thousands of Brits from the higher strata of society went out to remote parts of the world as colonial civil servants, military leaders, engineers, teachers, missionaries, doctors and merchants. Novels such as E. M. Forster’s “A Passage to India”, and the stories of Somerset Maugham and Rudyard Kipling, give very vivid portrayals of the lives these people led. There was also plenty of work for people from the lower classes, most notably as the foot soldiers who fought a long series of colonial wars right through the reign of Queen Victoria. Most of these people came home after a few years of service, but others settled permanently in the colonies, such as the owners of vast agricultural estates in Africa and tea plantations in India.

On the home front, many thousands of British people owed their livelihood to the Empire. The city of Birmingham became known as the “workshop of the world” for its manufacture of machinery and other goods that were exported largely to the colonies. New industries sprang up to process the raw materials and foodstuffs that were imported, such as rubber from Malaya and tea from India. Thousands of sailors, dockers and merchants made the import/export trade possible, and thousands more built the ships that carried the goods.

However, the British Empire was always a two-edged sword. Along with the benefits of Empire there were many reasons why Britain now looks back on it with shame as well as pride. It cannot be denied that massive injustices were done in the name of the Empire, and millions died in military actions, acts of genocide, and epidemics introduced to populations that had no defence to Western diseases. In the later Empire, the British governed without slavery, but servitude took its place, often harshly imposed. That said, British rule tended to be less brutal than that of some other colonial powers, most notably Belgium in the Congo.


The morality of Empire

This leaves aside the moral dimension of colonialism. Setting out to populate an empty land and wrest a living from a place that had never previously supported human life is one thing, but is it justifiable to, in effect, steal someone else’s country, maybe fighting the native people and killing many of them in the process? If you then impose your rule on the natives, insist on them adopting your religion and culture, and make them subservient to a monarch thousands of miles away, how can that possibly be justified?

In many cases, that is precisely what the builders of the British Empire did, and this process had an effect on the people back home as well as those in the new colonies. When you, as a nation, consider yourselves to be superior to other peoples, and to be citizens of the greatest nation on earth, you begin to think not only that you can do no wrong, but that you are a better human being than the colonized natives, who become seen as a sub-species of humanity who deserve the oppression that you are meting out to them. You begin to believe that these people can be enslaved because that is, after all, how they would treat each other, and that it is God’s will that you do so. In time, you, as the superior human, will become corrupted as your immoral acts and attitudes turn into moral ones in your own eyes.


Multicultural Britain


Today’s Brits look back at the days of Empire with mixed emotions. Apart from the fake patriotism mentioned at the beginning of this article, there is still a certain amount of pride in some quarters, but shame in others. The consequences of Empire are still with us today, in the form of the millions of our citizens whose parents or grandparents reversed the process and settled in Britain, mainly for economic reasons. Many of our cities have large non-white populations, and some will soon have a majority of their population who are not genetically native.

Multiculturalism has led to tensions and problems, and even riots at times. Most “natives” are happy to live in a rainbow nation, and to eat Indian takeaways and take part in the festivals that the immigrants have brought with them. However, others find this difficult, and there is therefore a considerable amount of racial prejudice that has led to race-hate crimes and accusations of “institutional racism” on the part of the Police and other organizations. Political parties that are racist, whether they admit it or not, enjoy periods of considerable support (although this is by no means the case at all times). Had the British Empire never existed, it is highly unlikely that Britain would be a multicultural nation today.


The Commonwealth

Although the British Empire as such has long gone, the Commonwealth that succeeded it is still in existence, presided over by Queen Elizabeth II. It still has some influence on world affairs but, apart from the spectacle of the four-yearly Commonwealth Games, it has little impact on the life of the average Briton. There is still a handful of colonies left, such as Pitcairn Island and St Helena, and we have even fought a colonial war in living memory, to defend the Falkland Islands against Argentina in 1982. However, apart from these occasional reminders of Empire, the effect of the British Empire on today’s British people is indirect. The same could hardly be said of past generations.



© John Welford